Hamilton finished with career high of 21 points -including seven in the second OT -- and 14 rebounds. Amauri Hardy added 18 points for UNLV (4-6, 1-0 Mountain West).
Hamilton hit a 3-pointer and then made a layup to give the Runnin' Rebels a 77-72 lead with 1:41 left in the game and then he and Tillman each made two free throws in the final minute to hold off Fresno State (2-5, 0-1).
UNLV extended its NCAA record to 1,080 consecutive games with at least one made 3-pointer.
Tillman made 1 of 2 free throws with 10 seconds left in the first OT to tie the game at 72 and then the Runnin' Rebels stole the ball so the Bulldogs couldn't get up a last shot.
UNLV forced the first overtime when Hamilton stole the ball with 29 seconds left and drove down the lane and banked in a short jumper with six seconds to go to tie the game at 65. Blackwell missed a long, potential winning 3-pointer at the buzzer.
For more AP college basketball coverage: https://apnews.com/Collegebasketball and http://twitter.com/AP-Top25
Flavors scores 21. California Baptist tops Bethesda 96-62
Ferron Flavors, Jr. scored 21 points on five 3-pointers, five players reached double digits and California Baptist ran away from Bethesda 96-62 Friday night.
Saturday's college basketball best bets: Fade Duke in a big conference game?
Our experts offer their best bets for Saturday's college basketball slate.
Wofford jets away to fast start, topples Furman 66-52
Chevez Goodwin scored 18 points and Nathan Hoover 17 as Wofford led from wire-to-wire and knocked off Southern Conference leader Furman, 66-52 Friday night.